Table of Contents
Get a Free Broker Opinion of Value
Request a confidential valuation from Robert Khodadadian. No obligation.
1. Get a Professional Valuation
Know what the building is worth before you list it. A professional valuation weighs the income approach (NOI and cap rates), comparable sales, replacement cost, and current market conditions.
Valuation Methods for NYC Commercial Property
Income Approach
Value = NOI ÷ Cap Rate. This is the primary method for income-producing properties. Current NYC cap rates range from 4-7% depending on property type and location.
Sales Comparison
Compare recent sales of similar properties in the area. Adjust for differences in size, condition, location, and tenant quality.
Replacement Cost
Land value plus construction cost minus depreciation. More relevant for newer buildings or special-use properties.
Pro Tip: Get a Broker Opinion of Value (BOV) from an experienced commercial broker. Unlike formal appraisals, BOVs are typically free, and a good one reflects what buyers are actually paying right now.
2. Choose Your Sales Strategy
Decide whether to sell on-market (publicly listed) or off-market (privately). Each has its trade-offs:
On-Market Sale
Public listing on CoStar, LoopNet, and broker networks.
- +Maximum exposure to buyers
- +Competitive bidding can drive price up
- +Clear market validation of price
- -Tenants and competitors know you're selling
- -Longer timeline typically
Off-Market Sale
Private sale to targeted, pre-qualified buyers.
- +Complete confidentiality
- +No tenant disruption
- +Work only with serious buyers
- +Faster closings possible
- -May miss the highest bidder
3. Select the Right Broker
The broker you pick moves both the sale price and the timeline. Look for:
What to Look for in a Commercial Broker
- Track Record: Closed deals in your property type and neighborhood
- Buyer Network: Relationships with active investors, funds, and family offices
- Market Knowledge: Knows current pricing and who is buying right now
- Marketing Capabilities: Quality materials, digital presence, and distribution
- Communication: Returns calls and sends updates before you have to ask
4. Prepare Your Property & Marketing
How the building shows, on paper and in person, affects what buyers will pay:
Document Organization
Gather rent rolls, operating statements (3 years), leases, tax returns, building plans, environmental reports, and capital improvement records.
Physical Preparation
Address deferred maintenance, clean common areas, improve curb appeal. Buyers price what they see on the tour.
Marketing Package
Professional photography, detailed Offering Memorandum (OM), financial pro forma, and investment highlights.
5. Review Offers & Negotiate
Price is only one line of an offer. Weigh buyer qualifications, timing, contingencies, and certainty to close:
Key Terms to Negotiate
Purchase Price
Total consideration, payment structure, any earnouts
Earnest Money Deposit
Typically 5-10% of purchase price, held in escrow
Due Diligence Period
30-60 days typical; shorter is better for sellers
Financing Contingency
Cash buyers preferred; mortgage contingencies add risk
Closing Timeline
30-45 days from contract for cash, 60-90 for financed
Representations & Warranties
Scope and survival period of seller guarantees
6. Due Diligence & Closing
Once under contract, the buyer will conduct due diligence. Be prepared to:
- Provide access for inspections (structural, environmental, mechanical)
- Supply all requested documents promptly
- Respond to tenant estoppel certificate requests
- Address title issues and obtain necessary clearances
- Negotiate any price adjustments based on findings
7. Tax Implications
Plan for the tax bill before you sign a contract. NYC sellers pay at several levels:
Expected Taxes When Selling in NYC
1031 Exchange Option
A 1031 like-kind exchange allows you to defer all capital gains taxes by reinvesting proceeds into replacement property within 180 days. It keeps the full sale proceeds working in your next property.Calculate your potential savings →
8. Frequently Asked Questions
What commission do commercial real estate brokers charge in NYC?
Commercial real estate commissions in NYC typically range from 2-6% depending on the deal size and complexity. Larger deals over $20M often have lower percentage rates, while smaller deals may command higher percentages. Commission structures are negotiable.
What taxes will I owe when selling commercial property in NYC?
When selling commercial property in NYC, expect federal capital gains tax (up to 20%), depreciation recapture (25%), NIIT (3.8%), NY State capital gains (8.82%), NYC capital gains (3.876%), and NYC/NYS transfer taxes (combined 2.625% for sales over $500K). A 1031 exchange can defer these taxes.
How long does it take to sell commercial property in NYC?
The typical timeline is 6-12 months from decision to close. This includes 2-4 weeks for preparation and pricing, 2-3 months for marketing and offers, 30-60 days for due diligence, and 30-45 days for closing. Off-market sales to qualified buyers can close in as little as 60-90 days total.
What commission do commercial brokers charge?
Commercial real estate commissions in NYC typically range from 2-6% of the sale price. Larger deals (over $20M) often have lower percentage rates, while smaller deals may command higher percentages. Commission structures are negotiable and may vary based on whether the sale is exclusive listing vs. open listing.
Should I sell with tenants in place?
It depends on your property and buyer pool. Stabilized properties with strong tenants often sell at premium prices because they provide immediate income. Some buyers, especially owner-users and redevelopers, would rather have the building vacant. A good broker will tell you which group is paying more right now.
What's the best time of year to sell?
Commercial real estate is less seasonal than residential, but activity typically peaks in Q1 and Q4 as investors deploy capital and manage year-end tax planning. Summer months can be slower. Still, a well-priced building will draw buyers in any month.